Effectivity’s darkish aspect: Technostress and the dehumanizing impression of tech

February 25, 2025

The GIST Editors' notes

This text has been reviewed based on Science X's editorial course of and insurance policies. Editors have highlighted the next attributes whereas guaranteeing the content material's credibility:

fact-checked

trusted supply

proofread

Effectivity's darkish aspect: Technostress and the dehumanizing impression of tech

Researcher warns against technostress
"The usage of know-how we see in lots of locations right this moment is solely dehumanizing," says Solveig Evenstad. She research how know-how impacts effectivity and well-being within the office. Credit score: Mads Wang-Svendsen

Solveig Beyza Narli Evenstad has turn out to be all too aware of the darkish aspect of the push for better effectivity, not solely by means of her analysis, but additionally in her personal life.

"After greater than 20 years of working to seek out new methods of enhancing effectivity, it step by step dawned on me that there aren’t any limits on how rapidly or how a lot folks ought to work," she says.

By then, Evenstad had herself reached a degree the place she felt burned out. It made her take a superb have a look at herself:

"Is it the know-how or the individuals who use it that I care most about?"

The reply she reached would set off a change of profession.

'There isn't a lot that scares me extra'

Evenstad is now an affiliate professor at NTNU in Gjøvik. A part of her work includes analysis on how know-how impacts effectivity and well-being in companies and organizations.

Regardless of her change of profession, she has on no account misplaced her love of know-how. Nonetheless, her hard-won experiences have given her a extra nuanced view of using know-how within the office.

"There's nonetheless not a lot that fascinates me as a lot as know-how and the numerous potentialities that it presents. However there isn't a lot that scares me extra both. The usage of know-how that we see in lots of locations right this moment is solely dehumanizing," mentioned Evenstad.

"Working life has already undergone intensive digitalization and automation, with 'doing extra with much less' as a guideline," she defined.

"We are actually additionally going through synthetic intelligence, which is not going to solely make us much more productive, but additionally result in basic adjustments within the nature of our work," she mentioned.

Technostress and alienation

New applied sciences provide many advantages, but in addition they current potential pitfalls. On condition that the tempo of growth is now sooner than ever earlier than, it’s also extra essential than ever that we’re outfitted to make smart selections, Evenstad mentioned.

"We can not blindly give in to the unending drive to do extra in much less time. If we continuously improve human beings by offering them with new know-how simply to make every thing work just a little bit sooner, there’s a hazard that little by little we’ll give away our autonomy and be decreased to nothing greater than a cog in a machine," she mentioned.

She believes that many individuals already really feel alienated and careworn by the technological developments at work.

"The truth that we now have began speaking about 'technostress' is a giant purple flag. Persons are fairly merely struggling to maintain up with developments and really feel like they by no means fairly handle to catch up," Evenstad mentioned.

On condition that newly launched know-how additionally presents superior surveillance capabilities, she believes that the alarm bells ought to actually be ringing now.

Sneaking beneath the radar

Lately, horror tales instructed by Amazon workers have raised eyebrows amongst many individuals.

Warehouse workers discuss having their "day off duties" monitored. In different phrases, each second not spent scanning or packing is logged. If the full time exceeds a sure variety of minutes, the worker will instantly obtain an routinely generated warning. Receiving a number of such warnings can result in dismissal, and former Amazon workers say they’ve even been fired by way of an app.

A New York Occasions survey discovered that eight of the highest ten non-public firms within the U.S. use related instruments to observe their workers.

"Applied sciences like this are sometimes launched on the pretext of boosting workers productiveness or smoothing out uneven workloads," defined Evenstad.

Moreover, some employers argue that a few of these applied sciences can enhance security and safety. For instance, some employers say that the know-how will assist forestall delicate data from falling into the unsuitable arms.

"It could be that real effectivity concerns or considerations about commerce secrets and techniques being leaked are concerned. Nonetheless, the truth that the know-how additionally entails problematic alternatives as regards monitoring and surveillance is just not at all times talked about as a lot," she mentioned.

Consequently, monitoring know-how tends to sneak beneath the radar.

A foothold already established in Europe

It isn’t simply within the U.S. that using monitoring and surveillance know-how is elevating considerations both. In response to analysis by the Eurofound Basis, related instruments are additionally being developed and utilized in Europe.

"Specifically, what is called 'bossware' is being launched in lots of locations," Evenstad mentioned.

This portmanteau of "boss" and "software program" is used to discuss with laptop packages that allow employers to observe their workers digitally.

"These are specialist instruments that may acquire information about all digital work-related exercise. Synthetic intelligence then analyses the info and generates work profiles for workers, managers and groups," she defined.

"Many functions which might be already an essential a part of the working lives of many Norwegians have related options," she mentioned.

"Instruments like Microsoft Viva, by means of Microsoft 365 apps (Groups, OneDrive, Outlook, SharePoint), assist to create a ubiquitous digital atmosphere the place information concerning the workers' actions are collected, analyzed and infrequently commercially exploited," she added.

This will appear comparatively innocent in contrast with what is going on within the U.S. Nonetheless, Evenstad is satisfied that we can not afford to be naïve.

"Microsoft was truly ordered to take away a function from Groups that gave managers a 'productiveness rating." The function assigned workers who spent numerous time on the web a low rating, whereas spending numerous time on e-mails led to a excessive rating," she defined.

The Norwegian mannequin might be beneath risk

The NTNU researcher believes that the EU's not too long ago adopted AI Act will probably be very important in regulating the event of this kind of software program sooner or later. Not solely will such packages very in all probability proceed to unfold, however synthetic intelligence might doubtlessly additionally take monitoring to completely new ranges.

"Synthetic intelligence is already effectively on the way in which to having the ability to learn your temper and interpret your feelings simply by taking a look at your face or listening to your voice," she mentioned.

She hardly dares take into consideration what this function might be used for have been it for use in a surveillance context.

The truth that know-how additionally presents problematic alternatives for monitoring and surveillance is just not at all times talked about as a lot.

"It might be something from cracking down on makes an attempt to determine or be part of a union, as Amazon is already making an attempt to do, to finishing up temper analyses, to be used in assessing your suitability for a job," she mentioned.

The EU's AI Act is due to this fact an essential and completely mandatory measure. On the identical time, it’s far too common for us to depend on alone, based on Evenstad.

"We’re completely depending on having a counterpart domestically within the office. Security delegates and elected representatives should have up-to-date data and consciousness of developments, in order that they’ll monitor them carefully. They need to even be far more concerned within the dialogue about which know-how must be launched within the office than is the case right this moment," she added.

In any other case, she fears for the way forward for the Norwegian mannequin, which is historically based mostly on values similar to participation, autonomy and belief.

"In response to a 2023 survey by the Fafo Analysis Basis, digital monitoring is simply being launched to a modest extent in Norway. However, extra analysis is required to acquire a clearer image of its extent. The query is how lengthy it would take for the U.S. strategy, with its widespread monitoring, to turn out to be frequent in sure industries right here, too," she mentioned.

'We should not enable ourselves to be pressured'

Evenstad can also be involved that this growth requires smart leaders.

"Managers have a duty to implement know-how responsibly. An excessive amount of give attention to checks and monitoring and a scarcity of belief in workers undermines worker motivation and harms efficiency and well-being," she mentioned.

Evenstad believes we must be cautious about utilizing know-how simply because others do.

"We should not enable ourselves to be pressured into maintaining with the remainder of the pack. It is important that we management the know-how earlier than it controls us," she concluded.

Supplied by Norwegian College of Science and Expertise Quotation: Effectivity's darkish aspect: Technostress and the dehumanizing impression of tech (2025, February 25) retrieved 25 February 2025 from https://techxplore.com/information/2025-02-efficiency-dark-side-technostress-dehumanizing.html This doc is topic to copyright. Other than any truthful dealing for the aim of personal examine or analysis, no half could also be reproduced with out the written permission. The content material is supplied for data functions solely.

Discover additional

Digital monitoring is not any substitute for engaged administration for distant work success, says examine shares

Feedback to editors